Sam Harris - Christian Terrorism and Islamophobia

Christian Terrorism and Islamophobia

image

At certain points near the extremity of human evil it becomes difficult, and perhaps pointless, to make ethical distinctions. However, I cannot shake the feeling that detonating a large bomb in the center of a peaceful city with the intent of killing vast numbers of innocent people was the lesser of Anders Behring Breivik’s transgressions last week. It seems to me that it required greater malice, and even less humanity, to have intended this atrocity to be a mere diversion, so that he could then commit nearly one hundred separate murders on the tiny Island of Utoya later in the day.

And just when one thought the human mind could grow no more depraved, one learns details like the following:

After killing several people on one part of the island, he went to the other, and, dressed in his police uniform, calmly convinced the children huddled there that he meant to save them. When they emerged into the open, he fired again and again. (“For Young Campers, Island Turned Into Fatal Trap.” The New York Times, July 23, 2011)

Other unsettling facts will surely surface in the coming weeks. Some might even be vaguely exculpatory. Is Breivik mentally ill? Judging from his behavior, it is difficult to imagine a definition of “sanity” that could contain him.

It has been widely reported that Breivik is a “Christian fundamentalist.” Having read parts of his 1500-page manifesto (2083: A European Declaration of Independence), I must say that I have my doubts. These do not appear to be the ruminations of an especially committed Christian:

I’m not going to pretend I’m a very religious person as that would be a lie. I’ve always been very pragmatic and influenced by my secular surroundings and environment. In the past, I remember I used to think;

“Religion is a crutch for weak people. What is the point in believing in a higher power if you have confidence in yourself!? Pathetic.”

Perhaps this is true for many cases. Religion is a crutch for many weak people and many embrace religion for self serving reasons as a source for drawing mental strength (to feed their weak emotional state f example during illness, death, poverty etc.). Since I am not a hypocrite, I’ll say directly that this is my agenda as well. However, I have not yet felt the need to ask God for strength, yet… But I’m pretty sure I will pray to God as I’m rushing through my city, guns blazing, with 100 armed system protectors pursuing me with the intention to stop and/or kill. I know there is a 80%+ chance I am going to die during the operation as I have no intention to surrender to them until I have completed all three primary objectives AND the bonus mission. When I initiate (providing I haven’t been apprehended before then), there is a 70% chance that I will complete the first objective, 40% for the second, 20% for the third and less than 5% chance that I will be able to complete the bonus mission. It is likely that I will pray to God for strength at one point during that operation, as I think most people in that situation would….If praying will act as an additional mental boost/soothing it is the pragmatical thing to do. I guess I will find out… If there is a God I will be allowed to enter heaven as all other martyrs for the Church in the past. (p. 1344)

As I have only read parts of this document, I cannot say whether signs of a deeper religious motive appear elsewhere in it. Nevertheless, the above passages would seem to undermine any claim that Breivik is a Christian fundamentalist in the usual sense. What cannot be doubted, however, is that Breivik’s explicit goal was to punish European liberals for their timidity in the face of Islam.

I have written a fair amount about the threat that Islam poses to open societies, but I am happy to say that Breivik appears never to have heard of me. He has, however, digested the opinions of many writers who share my general concerns—Theodore Dalrymple, Robert D. Kaplan, Lee Harris, Ibn Warraq, Bernard Lewis, Andrew Bostom, Robert Spencer, Walid Shoebat, Daniel Pipes, Bat Ye’or, Mark Steyn, Samuel Huntington, et al. He even singles out my friend and colleague Ayaan Hirsi Ali for special praise, repeatedly quoting a blogger who thinks she deserves a Nobel Peace Prize. With a friend like Breivik, one will never want for enemies.

One can only hope that the horror and outrage provoked by Breivik’s behavior will temper the growing enthusiasm for right-wing, racist nationalism in Europe. However, one now fears the swing of another pendulum: We are bound to hear a lot of deluded talk about the dangers of “Islamophobia” and about the need to address the threat of “terrorism” in purely generic terms.

The emergence of “Christian” terrorism in Europe does absolutely nothing to diminish or simplify the problem of Islam—its repression of women, its hostility toward free speech, and its all-too-facile and frequent resort to threats and violence. Islam remains the most retrograde and ill-behaved religion on earth. And the final irony of Breivik’s despicable life is that he has made that truth even more difficult to speak about.

Views: 30

Tags: Christianity, Harris, Islam, Norway, Sam, Terrorist, attack, terrorism

Comment

You need to be a member of Atheist Nexus to add comments!

Join Atheist Nexus

Comment by Sassan K. on July 26, 2011 at 4:03pm
Great point Proq Rock Girl. This guy has set back the anti-Islamic fascist movement by those now who are trying to make the false claim that "Christianity is just as violent as Islam" and "watch out for those right wing terrorists"
Comment by Lorien on July 26, 2011 at 3:06pm
He also said, Pat Condell is his favorite comedian! Oh NO.
Comment by Lorien on July 26, 2011 at 2:59pm

This is what he called himself:

 

Religion: Christian, Protestant but I support a reformation of Protestantism leading to it being
absorbed by Catholisism. The typical “Protestant Labour Church” has to be deconstructed as its
creation was an attempt to abolish the Church
Religious: I went from moderately to agnostic to moderately religious
Comment by Prog Rock Girl on July 26, 2011 at 2:22pm

And the final irony of Breivik’s despicable life is that he has made that truth even more difficult to speak about.

 

So true. Much like the far right's freaking out about Sharia. Legitimate anti-Sharia groups like One Law For All ended up being associated with them, and now being against Sharia makes some people think you're just a right-wing loony.

 

Does he really think that he will get the approval of Ibn Warraq and Ayaan Hirsi Ali by doing the same things as Islamic fundamentalists?

Comment by Sassan K. on July 26, 2011 at 2:21pm
This guy was no Christian fundamentalist. Jerry Falwell is a Christian fundamentilist. Pat Robertson is a Christian fundamentalist. This guy was and is an extremist - but no Christian fundamentalist.
Comment by Lorien on July 26, 2011 at 1:13pm

Have you read his 2083 document that he emailed out to the world. He is quite sane when he wrote it. His actions were wrong though. But it got the attention of the world.

 

Islam is a problem with no solution until there is a way to prove or demonstrate to the believers of all religions that there are no gods. Yes, it is quite obvious if you try but they don't want to try.

Comment by matt warren on July 26, 2011 at 11:38am

hay rational thinker.

how about we work to turn this around.

if BOTH sides are trying to blow each other and the rest of us up, then what the fuck is religion but a bunch of radicals trying to blow each other up and taking us with them.

we need to put the emphasis on the fact that atheists dont blow up people and places...religionists/nationalists do.

put the "bad" vibe on them.

atheists have nothing to do with this except for pointing this out.

and I think the world is batshit crazy if it does not realize this.
Comment by matt warren on July 26, 2011 at 11:30am

I havre made a study of serial killers / sex criminals etc...generaly psyco and sociopaths.

this person fits the description very well.

isolated, feelings of powerlessness against a percieved enemy. the man is NOT sick. he knows what he is doing. he had planned and executed (sic) his plan. this showes that he is NOT insane acording to leagal definition.

he is a classic sociopath that has let his destructive urges get the better of him.

these kind of people never really get well. he needs to be incarcerated for the rest of his life.

these are the kinds of people ON BOTH SIDES that need to be removed permanently from society.

I will never advocate just rounding people up. the rule of law says that untill a crime has been committed and proved beyond a shadow of a doubt you cant just toss people in prison.

that is if we really want a free world.

and I will say again that this man needs to be removed permanently from society.

Comment by Rational-Thinker on July 26, 2011 at 10:55am

Very good blog which brings to light the less obvious consequences of this idiot's actions.  He was clearly insane, and yet what will be focused on most is his hatred of Islam.  Actually, it will be refered to as his hatred of Muslims, as that's more a controversial phrasing.  I can even foresee the religious lot blaming his actions on atheism, they'll take anything they can get I suppose.

 

As you mentioned, this very important subject of the Islamification of Europe will be completely off limits now.  It was already a no-go area.  He has done more to hinder his cause that any Islamist could.  He was not a sane man, and definately not a rational one.

Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today

Donate

 

Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon

Amazon

AJY

 

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service