Religious Indoctrination as Child Abuse - Exhibit A: One Very Frightened Teen

While nosing about YouTube earlier today, I stumbled on a segment of The Atheist Experience, a public access show from Austin, Texas.  This show frequently features Matt Dillahunty, a former divinity student turned atheist and activist who comments on atheist-related issues and answers telephone calls and emails on the show.

As a part of a discussion regarding the indoctrination of children in this particular segment, Matt cites an email he has received from a 15-year-old.  This person wrote expressing doubts about his/her beliefs, yet did not research further into those doubts, saying that s/he was "scared out of my mind that there's a possibility that I'm wrong, and I feel like a heretic just thinking about it."

I heard that line and just shook my head in wonder and disgust ... that a CHILD was so frightened by a threat taught to him or her at a young and impressionable age that the idea of questioning something was unthinkable, as though that person were stranded in a minefield and one wrong move would result in an eternity of torture.  No one ... NO ONE should EVER have to live like that.

If I sound as though I'm a bit stressed about this business, it's largely because of an ongoing argument I'm involved in on another board with a theist. This person seems to think this is all a joke, that atheists needn't be taken seriously when they sound concerns about religious indoctrination of unsophisticated children, and that indeed, religious teaching is a harmless method of raising moral children. I wonder ... I do truly wonder if he has sufficient cojones to imagine how that 15-year-old kid who at least had sufficient bravery to write Matt was feeling, how scared, how conflicted ... and that it was those like this theist who were directly responsible for creating that condition, regardless of their intent. [sigh]

Anyhow ... the section I referred to in this video starts at approximately 2:06, but I strongly feel that the entire segment is worthy of your time and consideration.


Views: 113

Tags: Atheist Experience, Child Abuse, Matt Dillahunty, indoctrination

Comment

You need to be a member of Atheist Nexus to add comments!

Join Atheist Nexus

Comment by Loren Miller on January 14, 2012 at 10:14pm

Be nice if it worked, Glen ... but I'm dubious that parents' rights would be so easily overturned.  That's one of the bitches about being a realist - you have to deal with reality.

On the other hand, there's always lawsuits after the fact about parental malfeasance ... and, to be honest, that one wouldn't bother me in the slightest!

Comment by Glen Rosenberg on January 14, 2012 at 9:50pm

A modest proposal-Swift's work incidental-Parent's responsibility to avoid early indoctrination to be mandated by state. Scientists to determine age of parental prevarication and misrepresentation. Once children attain age of reason a modest introduction to the necromancers permissible-inclusive of mainstream and occult.

Failure to abide modest legalities results in forfeiture of parental rights-restoration of said rights contingent upon completion of course in rationalism and succesful demonstration of deconversion.

First amendment objection to modest proposal easily overcome-realization by supreme court how free exercise is neither free nor chosen when indoctrination is imposed at an early age.

Comment by Loren Miller on January 14, 2012 at 2:39pm

Another form of bully ... well stated!

Comment by Sentient Biped on January 14, 2012 at 2:37pm

I think a lot of us, who came from harsh religious backgrounds, have some post traumatic stress from abuse by religious indoctrinators.  It does not build character, it does not instill values or good judgement, and it can impose increased difficulties in life, even homelessness, depression, drug abuse, and suicide, for the vulnerable.  I don't think the harsh theist means well, they are just a type of bully  - like the Westboro Baptist Church assholes.

Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today

Donate

 

Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon

Amazon

AJY

 

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service