Indoctrination "is often distinguished from education by the fact that the indoctrinated person is expected not to question or critically examine the doctrine they have learned." (Wilson, J., 1964. "Education and indoctrination," (Manchester University Press). In other words, indoctrination is "dogmatic."
We need to distinguish between teaching children "what" to think from "how" to think for themselves, i.e., asking how we know what we know.

“Do not indoctrinate your children. Teach them how to think for themselves, how to evaluate evidence, and how to disagree with you.” (Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion)

Indoctrination is teaching children rote dogma, i.e., beliefs that are to be accepted on authority alone. Education on the other hand does not require uncritical acceptance of doctrine. Moreover, a good education encourages critical thinking and provides students with the cognitive toolkit to acquire knowledge for themselves, i.e. the scientific method. The scientific method is about asking why things work the way they do and how we know it, how we can test our hypotheses against the data -- not simply accepting things unquestioningly. If a child asks me what table salt is made of, I can reply, "Salt (NaCl) is a molecule consisting of one atom of sodium (Na) and one atom of Chlorine (Cl)," but I can also describe what that means and how we know that, how different elements behave, (their properties), and invite the child to test this for herself through experimentation. If a child asks me how old the earth is, I can explain how scientists estimate geological ages of things using radioactive isotopes, dendrochronology, plate tectonics, etc. to arrive at an estimate. The important point here is that scientific knowledge can be tested, at least in principle. A good hypothesis must be predictive, theoretically falsifiable, and open to revision. We need not hold beliefs dogmatically; we can go out and check how the world works, look at the evidence, and go where the evidence takes us. Scientists do not claim 100% percent certainty in their claims. If new data come in that conflict with the current model or theory, we must revise our theory. Indoctrination on the other hand requires only that we unquestioningly accept what we are told. Religious indoctrination is a good example. Religion is not self-revising. Religious "truths" are held dogmatically. Religious parents will often teach their children a collection of unfalsifiable bronze age myths that must, again, must be accepted on faith. But parents can opt to educate their children rather than indoctrinate them by teaching them how to think for themselves and by providing them access to teachers and scientists who can explain current theories and, more importantly, how we have arrived at them and how we can test our assumptions.

Views: 87

Comment

You need to be a member of Atheist Nexus to add comments!

Join Atheist Nexus

CONNECT WITH ATHEIST NEXUS

Latest Activity

Mr Peterdactyl replied to matthew greenberg's discussion Pope Francis says even Atheists go to Heaven
"I saw the Blitzer question on the evening news, I wanted to "throttle" him, as folks used to say. Wolf has trouble without a script, me thinks. I wish he would ask me that question, but then bleeps are not that interesting."
1 minute ago
Mathew T. replied to Jessica's discussion Just an interesting observation
"Very cool! Thanks for the follow up!"
2 minutes ago
Glenn Friedman commented on Yvette's group California Atheists
"anyone alive here in So Cali ? "
3 minutes ago
Mr Peterdactyl liked matthew greenberg's discussion Pope Francis says even Atheists go to Heaven
4 minutes ago
MB replied to Loren Miller's discussion Latest Activity?
"I don't want to be the "I don't like change cos its different" guy but I am having probs with the new layout. The main way I used this site was to scan through the new forums posts when i landed on the front page. Its great that…"
8 minutes ago
Ruth Anthony-Gardner replied to Joan Denoo's discussion Climate hits 400ppm of CO2 for first time in 3 million years in the group Climate Concerns
"Speaking of Michael Mann says we're raising Earth's temperature a million times faster than nature does. "
20 minutes ago
The Flying Atheist replied to booklover's discussion Even More FB Finds...
"Now I know why I always get dirty looks when I dance.  I've been using the length of the World's Smallest Bible as a measuring guide.  There's not much room for the Holy Spirit, especially when I'm excited.   "
32 minutes ago
The Flying Atheist commented on Ruth Anthony-Gardner's group Hang With Friends
"Angela, we had our torrential rain and thunderstorm last night here in northern Illinois.  Lots of heavy rain and gusty winds.  Pretty intense.  My lights flickered a few times.  I thought I was going to lose power but luckily…"
50 minutes ago

© 2013   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service