"Good ideas, Prytanis. Having studied Memetics and the anthropology/neuroscience/psychology of religious belief, I want to make sure we understand that the power of religious belief in humans is deep seated. One example is that in human development…"
"I don't think you can create a worldwide movement around an idea that's based on a negative. The term atheist is kind of negative sounding even if it isn't literally negative. A viral meme needs to supercede all other memes in a way…"
"Trouble is the description of religions is not true. Sure religious groups can do these things, just like any group can. However, it is not true to say that religions bring nothing but war and death to humanity. They can do much good also. The…"
"1. Try gently suggesting personal responsibility to (initially) augment moral authority. Faith doesn't preclude attempts to be 'like Christ'. And, in the face of their version of free will, personal responsibility isn't excluded,…"
"Right on: Fight Club is the bible of our generation.
Hey - I'm probably older than you given that statement - but I get what you are saying, nonetheless.
I live in Tom Paines other hometown (not Philly) and consider him the greatest of the…"
Jim Ashby: Comment by Prytanis on 5 September 2008 at 11:57pm
I've really wanted to find a group of people to discuss this subject with, and to test some ideas that I've had about it recently. I didn't think I'd actually find a compatibilist (Jim Ashby) with which to debate! Frankly, I'm overjoyed, as it means that there is a rare breed here with whom I can debate. Very exciting.
Unless you are a masochist, there is no point. You are on a spiral into nothingness arguing with Ashby. Ref - there are many, many more. Read the whole thread - if you have the stamina. This summarises it.