I get the satire but this is not going to help much. As someone else said here, its only going to add to the martyr complex. A better strategy towards undoing the Jesus myth would be to put it on par with all the other mythic stories out there, like Hercules, Santa Claus, Krishna, Ra, Mitras, Jupiter, Xenu, Anguta, Gautama etc etc.
This is an atheist version of what PETA does for vegetarianism. You can love it or hate it. Many people who have christianity, christian practices, forced on them have a lot of anger, and seeing both the sign and T-shirt are kind of liberating.
I'm personally not an in-your-face type of guy. Still, I laughed at this poster, and I like the T-shirt a lot.
Comment by MP Lockwood on April 27, 2009 at 2:05pm
I do believe in the right to offend, but have to side with Amanda that atheists ought to take the high road. A common Christian tactic is the "you're just as intolerant as we are" argument. This guy's just helping them to believe that. I don't think this sign will encourage anyone to question their belief in Jesus. If anything, it feeds their martyr story.
You say that "Jesus was crucified" like it is an established fact. I think it is unlikely that such a person ever existed and if he did the idea that he was important enough to be given a public show trial and execution is very much in doubt.
The idea that he thought differently is also questionable with many of the teachings attributed to Jesus were simply lifted from previous god heads (I haven't got time to reference this statement today so I'll leave it with you or we can come back to it if you like).
I don't want to acceptance by religious people. I want the majority to give up their unfounded beliefs in magic fairies. Not all people and their beliefs deserve respect and giving them respect only seems to make them want more and more respect... a little respect for nonsense might be termed 'gateway respect' if one were to believe the gateway drug hype.
The right to offend is one that is taken constantly by the religious. We see them offending constantly under the guise of religious beliefs saying some of the most outrageous things like gay people are inherently flawed and atheists don't have any morality. Why should I protect these people from being offended when they are spewing offence at me all the time.
Darwin Bedford is really out there but he is a public figure and I am more on his side of this culture war than the people he is attacking. His extreme views give non-theists more room to move and I commend him for his activity.
That is awful. Jesus was crucified because his religious beliefs didn't match that of the majority. You guys want to be killed for daring to think differently? That kind of religious intolerance is exactly what we should be fighting against in order to gain acceptance.
"Free-thinker" was a popular term in the 19th century amongst atheists and I see no reason why it shouldn't be re-activated. It captures the Enlightenment ideals of thinking and investigation without fear or prejudice. For the British amongst us Cha…
I think this ignores one simple and demonstrable fact: Beginning with the 17th century enlightenment, there has been a gradual movement away from religious faith. An increase in knowledge about nature has offered a competing theory about life's orig…
The other day I was talking to an old friend and she was telling me "you know Diaddy when rapture comes, dont you want your kids to go to heaven?' My son (who is 9) came out of the room and told her "woman dont you know I dont believe in god? dont w…
I was having lunch today with a bunch of my coworkers, and the topic drifted into the subject of religion (I promise, I didn't do it). The group consisted of three agnostics (including myself), a Catholic, a liberal Christian, and my boss, who is a…
This group will do more than just pick apart biblical errors and contradictions. Let's closely examine the Bible and Qur'an. Nothing is sacred; every prophecy, proverb, and parable deserves examination and critique.
Hi everyone,I grew up in a Christian home, and for 30 years I was quite dedicated to it. A couple of years ago, I think it was in 2004 or 2005, I lost all faith in the religion. So here I am. Atheist since 5 years, and I can see any reason why ever…
This sounds like many doable ideas and I don't mean to be a killjoy but.....the local atheist group I belonged to for several yrs managed to get tax exempt status so donations could be deductable and that took them almost a yr. Gov't agencied weren'…
You need to be a member of Atheist Nexus to add comments!
Join this Ning Network