What are your thoughts on the relationship between obedience and conformity vs. the moral behavior of individuals?

As a free thinker, obedience is one of my most poignant fears. There are countless myriad examples of generally decent individuals performing heinous crimes under the authority of others. Experiments on these matters are equally frightening.

Links to wikis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asch_conformity_experiments
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment

Most atheists are by definition non-conformists to some degree on another. What do you think makes it possible for you to stand your ground where others fail?

Tags: authority, conformity, obedience

Views: 8

Replies to This Discussion

Interesting article, but I find the study itself too limited and narrow. Also, what about women who generally are supposed to react strongly towards spiders, wounded and weak? This creates a bias not including this into this sort of study I think, because then naturally women would actually be less liberal...?
Studies published in a journal such as Science tend to control for simple things like that. Unfortunately brief articles about such studies tend to *not* include such information. This case was no exception. Here's an example of what the study actually said about this:

"Uncontrolled, bivariate results have the potential to mislead. We therefore regressed each participant's summary level of support for socially protective political policies on changes in skin conductance as well as on four sociodemographic variables commonly used as predictors of political attitudes: gender, age, income, and education (race and ethnicity were not controlled because all but one participant was self-identified as white and non-Hispanic). With the effects of these sociodemographic variables controlled, the effect of increases in skin conductance when viewing threatening stimuli was positive and significant (P < 0.01), with a large standardized regression coefficient (0.377)"
What do you think makes it possible for you to stand your ground where others fail?

It's my hardcore, dictionary-thumping bond to actually being right. Before I got covered in shame for a few years, in fourth grade for example I'd correct teachers on stuff that they got wrong--each and every time. If the postman stopped to chat with my mom for a second and he got the troposphere confused with the stratosphere I'd bust right in with a correction. This just extends to extra-moment-acious things, too.

Put blue paint on the sign when we were told to use red? Afterwards they will say "That was wrong." I shall be right! We will use red!

RSS

CONNECT WITH ATHEIST NEXUS

Latest Activity

Randall Smith posted a blog post

The Rednecks are coming, the Rednecks are coming

Actually, the rednecks are here and everywhere. Let me say, I'm not a big fan of these people. That's putting it mildly. Need I describe them? You know who I mean.This seems to be the time of year when they come out of the woodwork. Here in Indiana, as the weather gets nice, the motorcyclists are out in full force. I hate the noise cycles make. Then there's the Indianapolis 500 fans, the majority of which are rednecks. Interview them or a typical Pacer fan (big news as they face the Miami…See More
1 hour ago
Loren Miller commented on Joan Denoo's photo
Thumbnail

Tunisian Women 4

"War is Peace.Ignorance is Strength.Freedom is Slavery.and...Rape is the woman's fault?  No, sorry, too much of a stretch, even for George Orwell."
1 hour ago
Dennis Michael Pennington commented on Debra Stevenson's blog post Pope's 'exorcism' caught on film video
"Maybe so. Ad that the Pope has no power over anything or anybody except for the power given to him by the office and the world at large today."
1 hour ago
Dennis Michael Pennington commented on matthew greenberg's blog post War on Christmas in May
"Happy Holidays is a good enough saying for anyone at Christmas time. I support the phrase "happy holidays" rather than the bullshit most Americans were taught. Let's go back in time to look at meanings here. "Holidays"…"
1 hour ago
leveni commented on Joan Denoo's photo
1 hour ago
leveni commented on Joan Denoo's photo
2 hours ago
leveni commented on Joan Denoo's photo
2 hours ago
Loren Miller replied to Loren Miller's discussion Latest Activity?
"And now I see that Latest Activity has been restored to my profile page (and, I presume, everyone else's).  Thanks for the effort, Richard."
2 hours ago

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2013   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service