Editor's note: John Anderson is a film critic for Variety and The Wall Street Journal, and a contributor to The New York Times. He is the author of "Sundancing" (2000) and "I Wake Up Screening" (2006).

(CNN) -- When Iranian director Asghar Farhadi accepted his Golden Globe for best foreign film last month, he spoke a few words of thanks, paused and announced he wanted to say something about his people. Two nations held their breath.

"They are a peace-loving people," Farhadi said, and then was gone. Brief though it was, his comment was eloquent, to the point and unsettling in its simplicity.

Likewise his movie. Much of the reason that "A Separation" has made such an impact in the West -- a virtual sweep of the critics' prizes, a Golden Globe and two Oscar nominations, including a virtually unheard of nod for a non-U.S. screenplay -- is that it isn't a foreign film at all (except for all that Farsi).

If anything, it's a feel-good movie, albeit in a wildly perverse way: Having experienced the anguish of Farhadi's characters, the viewer comes away with the inescapable sense of our common humanity, the resounding sense that we're all in this life together. If that sounds clichéd, so be it.

This is not a politically acceptable position, of course.

Amid the glib militarism of Republican presidential candidates, the bellicosity of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and the nuclear recklessness of the mullahs, "A Separation" drives home the oft-ignored fact that Iran is full of educated, sophisticated and cultured people who don't necessarily agree with their government either. Particularly the lead characters of "A Separation."

Farhadi doesn't ask for trouble. No one in the cast declares that, "Our impossible, infuriatingly theocratic regime is anti-intellectual, anti-opportunity, anti-woman, anti-freedom, anti-human." Nevertheless, Simin (Leila Hatami) wants out. A young mother of Tehran's educated middle-class, she wants a better life for her daughter, Termeh (played by the director's daughter, Sarina Farhadi) and -- why not? -- a better life for herself.

She works, she takes classes, she harbors an intellectual curiosity. Under her hijab, her hair is dyed an unnatural but quite chic shade of red, which more or less reflects her disposition. She is adamant. She's going, whether her husband, Nader, is willing or not. And he's not. His father is suffering from dementia and can't be left behind. And, as Islamic law demands that the husband decides where the daughter goes, Termeh is staying, too.

Without giving away the whole plot, it's worth saying that "A Separation" snowballs into a demi-tragedy propelled by institutional hubris: Simin is judged by the system to have insufficient grounds for divorce, but what can happen otherwise when the grounds for her request are the very system that is denying her the divorce?

Nader, needing to find a housekeeper who can care for his father while he goes to work, rashly hires Razieh (Sareh Bayat), a woman so fearful of religious impropriety that she has to call for a ruling before she can change the incontinent old man out of his soggy clothes. That she cannot touch Nader's father, played by Ali-Asghar Shahbazi, lest she violate some religious tenet, verges on the absurdly comedic. The series of misunderstandings and various acts of dishonesty that intertwine so gracefully and with such a dreadful sense of destiny, are all predicated on a system that denies reality.

Read the rest here.


I'll admit to not being a great "small film" or "significant film" person.  Give me my "Inception" and "Iron Man" and "Sherlock Holmes" and I'm fine, most times.  Still, I saw this story on the CNN.com home page this morning and thought, "what the heck," and now I'm curious to see "A Separation" and what this Iranian filmmaker has brought to the screen.

As it is, I have a friend on another board who lives in Iran.  She somehow made it through the madness of the last election and sees very clearly through the BS or Ahmadinejad, Khamenei, and the mullahs, though she like her peers is largely impotent to do anything about them.  I haven't heard from her in a while and I worry ... and I wonder if a film like this can make a difference, not just for us, but for them.

Tags: A Separation, Asghar Farhadi, Iran

Views: 67

Replies to This Discussion

By coincidence, have just read in the TLS that Ahmadinejad has claimed since 2005 that he is the voice of the Hidden Imam and is therefore infallible. What a load of crap!

Say WHAT?!?  And just what does Ayatollah Ali Khamenei have to say about that???  [HOOBOY!]

{BTW, what's the TLS?}

Thanks for the suggestion, I've added it to my watchlist


Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today



Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon




Latest Activity

Future replied to Joan Denoo's discussion Scientists warn we are on the brink of the next major mass extinction event
4 minutes ago
DAN DANA posted a photo
5 minutes ago
Pat commented on Loren Miller's status
8 minutes ago
Profile IconDAN DANA, nice girl, KOUSTAV GUHA and 3 more joined Atheist Nexus
19 minutes ago
Randall Smith commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
30 minutes ago
Trick replied to Anthony Jordan's discussion Free Will [Sam Harris]
44 minutes ago
Trick replied to Anthony Jordan's discussion Free Will [Sam Harris]
58 minutes ago
Sentient Biped commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
1 hour ago
Loren Miller posted a status
"Has anyone else noticed that A|N links to comments aren't working? You get to the post, but not to the exact comment. Something's broke!"
1 hour ago
Loren Miller commented on Bertold Brautigan's blog post Do We Exist?
1 hour ago
Lord Ainsworth liked Freethinker31's blog post We Are Not Alone in the Universe
2 hours ago
Idaho Spud commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
2 hours ago

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service