What evidence would you require to believe in a higher power?

It always has bewildered me being in a scientific field that there are so many religious scientists. I had one pose a question to me the other day, one that I honestly had never considered before.  I would like to pose it to the community and see others requirements.  

What evidence would make you change your mind and start believing in a higher power? My first response was obviously others must have had the same, simultaneous experience to ensure I was not in the middle of a stroke, hallucinating etc... Beyond this, what requirements should be have.

Naturally, I posed the question back to the religionist, and of course the answer was no evidence would convince them that their god was not real.

Views: 1307

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Whatever the evidence would be, it would HAVE to be objective, testable, and consistent as all get-out.  There could be no presuppositions as to WHICH god was revealing itself, and any analysis would have to be done from a clean sheet of paper.  Also, keep in mind:

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
-- Arthur C. Clarke

We could as easily be dealing with a highly advanced alien or aliens as with some form of deity ... which brings another point: How Do You Even DEFINE a "Higher Power?!?"

Oh, and yet another point: as it comes to me, at least (and probably most everyone else here), we wouldn't be talking about "belief;" we'd be talking about KNOWLEDGE.  I have no faith, have no use for faith, and those things I believe have considerable substance behind them.  Belief in things unseen is a complete non-starter with me.

And one last point: maybe some deity does manage to show itself and is verified as such.  Terrific, we now KNOW that there is a god.  Does that mean I WORSHIP said god?  Ohhhhhhh, guess again, Skippy!

Loren, love your reply.  I agree with the Arthur C. Clarke quote, and your take on advanced aliens.

And, thanks for the laugh: "guess again, Skippy!"

God would have to show himself during the Superbowl.  and it better not be a trick!

The Superbowl already has too many commercials.  We don't need this on top of it.  Oh, and insofar as half-time entertainment is concerned, he/she/it would do well to have a better show than The Who did a couple years back, if he wants any cred at all!

I would be pretty disappointed if god showed up on Super Bowl Sunday. Any other Sunday, please .... I'd like to enjoy the game.

I've seen some Christian movies about the Rapture, Jesus coming back and talking to someone incognito, then revealing himself by doing miraculous things.

It would seem very bizarre if the Christians suddenly got raptured, etc. - like having a book superimposed on the universe.  I would be quite discombobulated and freaked out, at least. 

If the gawd thing came out from behind the clouds, & suddenly the whole world had provably enough food regularly, no birth defects or diseases, no raping & murder, especially of the tiny ones, religious wars, killer disasters, I MIGHT begin to think something may be behind it. But as for worshipping something that didn't do these things from the start......I doubt it. Too damn much to answer for, & none of it forgivable. 

I agree Patricia,  he would have "too damn much to answer for".

How would you know what "he" had in the genital area? 

Sorry, just force of habit from 50 years indoctrination.

Same way anyone else does ... examination ... presuming he/she/it has legs to look between in the first place!

You think advanced aliens would let you go peering under their clothing? 

Would you know the difference between God and advanced aliens by their behavior? 

RSS

Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today

Donate

 

Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon

Amazon

AJY

 

Latest Activity

Kelvin Hilerio posted a status
"About to play Tearaway later 2night!"
9 minutes ago
Christine posted a discussion
12 minutes ago
Freethinker31 replied to Joan Denoo's discussion My gravesite inscription
14 minutes ago
Will-I Am S. replied to scott martins's discussion IS EVERYBODY 100% POSITIVE THERE IS NO GOD?
16 minutes ago
Freethinker31 replied to Joan Denoo's discussion How Creationists in Texas Are Pressuring Schoolbook Publishers to Bring God into Biology
21 minutes ago
Malcolm Grant Hutton replied to Malcolm Grant Hutton's discussion Impossible Numbers in the Bible in the group Christian Biblical Errancy Debate
22 minutes ago
Freethinker31 liked Joan Denoo's discussion How Creationists in Texas Are Pressuring Schoolbook Publishers to Bring God into Biology
24 minutes ago
Joseph P replied to Joe's discussion The IRS Says It Will Finally Enforce the Rules Barring Pastors from Endorsing Candidates from the Pulpit in the group Atheist News
29 minutes ago
Kelvin Hilerio replied to Joan Denoo's discussion How Creationists in Texas Are Pressuring Schoolbook Publishers to Bring God into Biology
33 minutes ago
Will-I Am S. replied to scott martins's discussion IS EVERYBODY 100% POSITIVE THERE IS NO GOD?
35 minutes ago
Freethinker31 replied to scott martins's discussion IS EVERYBODY 100% POSITIVE THERE IS NO GOD?
42 minutes ago
Loren Miller replied to Joe's discussion The IRS Says It Will Finally Enforce the Rules Barring Pastors from Endorsing Candidates from the Pulpit in the group Atheist News
42 minutes ago

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service