RNs fired for refusing flu vaccine. Claims christian faith exemption.
Influenza kills somewhere between 3,000 to 40,000 Americans annually. According to the Centers for Disease Control " from the 1976-1977 season to the 2006-2007 flu season, flu-associated deaths ranged from a low of about 3,000 to a high of about 49,000 people." with an average of about 25,000 deaths per year.
So far this year, there have been 18 pediatric deaths. It's very early in the season. Last year there were 34. The year before that, 122, and the year before that, 282. That might appear to be a downward trend, but it really reflects that influenza strains are highly variable from year to year, and there is an ebb and flow of deaths.
282 child deaths is how many Newtown massacres?
figure from above link,
The fact is, every person who has influenza is a vector for others to catch it. The vaccine is not 100% effective, but it's the best thing we have to reduce epidemic impact and save lives. It's not about someone with a few aches and pains, fever and a chance to watch old movies and wear pajamas. It's about reducing the # of tragedies. All of those hundreds of children who died in the past 4 years had parents who grieved just as much as Newtown parents grieved.
It's hard to predict, butthis season looks like it could be a doozy. I hope not. Of course there are flawed predictions. It's an inexact science.
So that's the context for why this nurse pisses me off. She wants to continue working in a hospital, where she could contract influenza, and potentially infect many others before developing symptoms herself. It's not that easy to differentiate flu from bronchitis from cold, in the early stages.
Plus, it's being taken as a case for religious freedom: "
'I feel like in my personal faith walk, I have felt instructed not to get a flu vaccination, but it’s also the whole matter of the right to choose what I put in my body..."
Sue Schrock, a hospice nurse, said she has not had a flu vaccine for 30 years as a result of a choice she made because of her Christian faith."
Alan Phillips, who represented several nurses at the hospital, says his clients had the right to refuse their flu shots under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits religious discrimination of employees. Religion is legally broad under the First Amendment, so it could include any strongly held belief, he said, adding that the belief flu shots are bad should suffice.
I don't know how the "rights" aspect will turn out. If a hospital worker claimed they couldn't wear mask or gloves in surgery because of their religion, how would that go over? But they won't, so that's a moot point.
All I know is it pisses me off and sets a bad example.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by James Kz on -
Rights in a court case are balanced against each other.
The nurses in question might have the religious right to refuse a vaccine, but that has to be balanced against the public's right not to be infected.
I suspect should this actually go to court, they will lose.
-
Permalink Reply by Humble Pie on -
This will go the same way as people whose religion bars paying social security taxes. The government said they were A-OK with that. The people just couldn't work. HA!
-
Permalink Reply by Susan Stanko on -
They also have a right to find another job.
-
Permalink Reply by booklover on -
I agree Susan. If the nurse is that dumb, she shouldn't be in a job where she is compromising other people's health.
-
Permalink Reply by Sentient Biped on -
Absolutely. And not just a different job in the hospital, in administration as others suggest. That displaces someone who might be better qualified, better suited, trained, etc, in favor of someone who gives her religion, if that is really the case, priority over public health and health of the patient.
I wonder if her religion is really the issue - I don't think Jesus had much to say about influenza vaccines, and Leviticus is mute on the topic as well.
-
Permalink Reply by Michael Brice on -
No matter your stance on vaccination, a vaccination is an invasive medical procedure, doesn't a U.S. citizen have the right to refuse them?
*spelling edit*
-
Permalink Reply by Susan Stanko on
-
Not if they work in the public health sector
-
Permalink Reply by Susan Stanko on
-
Now that I think about it. Anyone who actually wants to be around a lot people, like school kids, should have to vaccinated. Kids shouldn't be dying just because somebody doesn't want to be vaccinated. Which is why kids entering school have mandatory vaccinations.
-
Permalink Reply by Sentient Biped on
-
Also ditto from me. It's reasonable to expect that people, who work among those especially vulnerable to influenza, have taken precautions in the interest of safety for children and hospital patients.
I guess the expression "invasive procedure" needs some definition. If a simple shot - or in some cases, a nose spray - is invasive, then how do we define colonoscopy? Open heart surgery? I don't think a shot is invasive.
Around here schools require that employees either be vaccination, or that they have blood tests to verify immunity.
What would happen if some kids contracted influenza and one or more died (as happens) and it was shown that their un-immunized teacher had influenza and exposed the kids? In addition to parental grief, would there be a lawsuit? Similar for patients in hospital - if RN caring for patients had influenza, and was not immunized, and patients died as a result - same thing?
I don't know the answers to those. But as far as ethics goes, I think every person in healthcare or child care should be vaccinated.
Members
-
Patricia Online
-
Two Cult Survivor Online
-
matthew greenberg Online
Blog Posts
War on Christmas in May
Posted by matthew greenberg on May 21, 2013 at 12:18pm 3 Comments 0 Likes
i've got no problem with everyone saying "merry christmas" on christmas day. however, they've turned it into an entire holiday season where it lasts a month or more. in those situations it should be perfectly acceptable to say "happy holidays" or call it a…
Continue
My first funeral as an atheist
Posted by Two Cult Survivor on May 21, 2013 at 11:30am 0 Comments 0 Likes
I posted the bulk of this on another thread, but wanted to add some context separately.
I finally confronted my faith and embraced the fact of my atheism late last August, 2012. Days after I revealed my "epiphany" to a few friends who knew me from another message board, my sister died from Lou Gehrig's Disease (which pissed her off because she hated catching a disease from someone she never f---ed).
THAT was my sister, understand? She was a beautiful, life-loving, potty-mouthed…
Continue
Death of a family member
Posted by Larry Taylor on May 20, 2013 at 8:15pm 10 Comments 2 Likes
OK. I am venting. My mother died two weeks ago. She was a “god fearing christian.” Before her death she refused all medical treatment. She wanted to be left alone. She even refused to speak with my brother who is a methodist minister. He is a pip, let me tell you! I suspect she did not believe, but a woman born in her time could not and did not state her actual beliefs. This is the opening salvo to all christians; FUCK YOU! I had so many people come and tell…
Continue
Unbelievable!!!!!!!!
Posted by Christy Stewart on May 20, 2013 at 2:17pm 6 Comments 0 Likes
This probably should not have shocked me as much as it did (especially since I am in Texas). I actually thought my coworkers were playing a joke on me because they know I am an atheist. Sadly, this was no joke. This actually happened.
I work in a psychiatric hospital. The doctors who admit patients are general MDs. (Psychiatrists see patients after admission) Yesterday evening we received several calls from irate parents. A new doctor who was doing admissions yesterday actually…
ContinueEvents
© 2013 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.
