Yesterday, I had a discussion with my neighbor about Obamacare. He is conservative and opposed to it on the grounds that it restricts his personal freedom not to have insurance. He is about my age (late 70's).  I pointed out that he is on Medicare with a good secondary insurance from his former employer and is therefore unaffected by ACA, his reply was that he would be if he didn't have insurance and that was enough to make him mad.

The argument that the uninsured use emergency rooms for which he pays indirectly through increased hospital costs did not make any difference to him since he never sees those costs explicitly. The man is a retired software engineer and might be expected to understand things better, but his rightwing mindset prevents it. He said he preferred the country he grew up in where you still had choices. In that country—before Medicare—one third of people our age lived below the poverty line.

This illustrates the difficulty in getting people to understand public issues. Once the issues have been framed in an emotional setting, reason departs.

Views: 561

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Maybe I'll just start SMILING AT HER.  Every time I see her, I'll give her a BIG GRIN. LOL!  She'll wonder what I'm up to! ha ha

Tom, sounds like a good moment for you! Sweet and powerful! I wonder if the priest gave your comment some thought? 

Joan, the practicing Catholics I know are able to parrot arguments that fit onto bumper stickers, as this rather young priest did.

I don't trust them to be capable of independent thought.

I have given her all those examples Loren, and more than once.  She just talks over me, and refuses to hear what I'm saying.  She's d-u-m-b dumb. I'm not even going to exchange pleasantries with her, because as soon as that's over, she STARTS. lol. 

The ACA, if it is to work at all, should have been a single payer system.  The business model for all insurance schemes is simple: Collect as much money as possible, from the greatest number of payers as possible and pay out as little as possible. Anybody could make money with this scheme.

A single-payer system would be much better, but it seems to be politically impossible in the USA at this point. Whether the restrictions on the insurance offered through the exchanges will prevent the abuse you anticipate is a good question, but at least people will be able to get insurance of some kind and for many people that is a major improvement in their lives.

I agree Dr. Clark.  Of course this was the best that the Democrats could get passed.  Single-payer should be the way to go.  I agree it's politically impossible though, and that's sad.

In the meantime we should not let conservatives get away with the argument that Obamacare is socialism. Requiring people to buy health insurance from private profit-making companies is very far from socialism.

I could not agree more.  I just find that the conservatives I know and try and talk to about this issue just will not listen.  They will not concede ANY points.  It's infuriating.

The dogmatic conservative style in argument is not a new phenomenon and quite tiresome, but it should not prevail due to a lack of challenge. Conservatives imagine they have won the argument when all they have done is repeat canned arguments learned from Limbaugh et al.

Agreed. Having a profit-making health insurance does not meet the needs of this great nation. Are we really so skeptical about the population that we can't even imagine it ever happening here? 

Let me think. Everybody pays into a system that includes health delivery systems to urban and rural, that doctors are available for all who need the skilled professionals, that physician assistants and nurses strategically placed around the country to meet the need for less skilled diagnostic and treatment the people need, and no one is denied access to care. 

Take the money out of warring, colonizing, collect taxes from churches, and have no loopholes or off shore hideaways for earnings or profits. It seems doable to me. 

I watched a video on YouTube about this awesome Dr. in Pittsburgh, who goes around at night, with a formerly homeless friend, and helps the homeless on his own time and money.  Cleans wounds, gives antibiotics, checks blood-pressures, etc.  It was about going on housecalls to people without houses.  Wonderful Dr.!!

RSS

Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today

Donate

 

Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon

Amazon

MJ

Latest Activity

Pat replied to matthew greenberg's discussion Teh Stoopid...it's killing me!!
6 minutes ago
Sentient Biped commented on Claire Donnelly's group LGBTQI atheists, nontheists, and friends
10 minutes ago
Anthony Jordan commented on Bryan McDowell's blog post Proving a Negative
17 minutes ago
James M. Martin replied to James M. Martin's discussion Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Why "Cosmos" Will NOT be Accompanied by Creationist Explanation for...well...the Cosmos
35 minutes ago
James M. Martin replied to James M. Martin's discussion Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Why "Cosmos" Will NOT be Accompanied by Creationist Explanation for...well...the Cosmos
39 minutes ago
Idaho Spud replied to James M. Martin's discussion Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Why "Cosmos" Will NOT be Accompanied by Creationist Explanation for...well...the Cosmos
53 minutes ago
Dr. Allan H. Clark replied to Alan's discussion The reason why the United States has such a higher rate of religion compared to the UK
57 minutes ago
k.h. ky commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
59 minutes ago
Tom Sarbeck replied to matthew greenberg's discussion Teh Stoopid...it's killing me!!
1 hour ago
Grinning Cat replied to James M. Martin's discussion Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Why "Cosmos" Will NOT be Accompanied by Creationist Explanation for...well...the Cosmos
1 hour ago
k.h. ky replied to James M. Martin's discussion Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Why "Cosmos" Will NOT be Accompanied by Creationist Explanation for...well...the Cosmos
1 hour ago
k.h. ky commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
1 hour ago

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service