"Joan, that is so nice of you to include the woman with no support-system!!!! I'm glad it's going okay.
Steph, adorable cat pic. :) I know you'll do great in your classes! ~ Melinda/Mindy/Booklover, lol"
 |
The World's Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!
Oh Hell...
The absurdity of this argument just compels me so much to call it out. It seems that the only thing the threat of hell seems to be saying is that if you don't believe that there is a hell to go to after you die for not believing in hell while you are alive, then you will go to hell. Or, to put it another way, if you don't believe what we believe in, then you will get punished in the way which you don't believe you will get punished in... but you will! Or still more absurdly, believe in what I believe in or you will suffer. How? Well, you'll have to die to find out.
It would be giggle-worthy if we didn't actually have to deal with people who think like this and actually threaten us with going to hell for thought-crimes, that is, not believing in the same delusions to which they have fallen prey. Particularly when it comes to children. The thought of threatening children that they will go to an imaginary place for not believing in said imaginary place and for not subscribing to the same fairy tales and fantasies that give rise to such a monstrous place angers me. As if a child could immediately realize the farcicality (I think I just made up a word) of a creator-god who punishes his creations for how he made them.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Larry Taylor on -
Along the same line of thought; it amazes me that the same people who tell us god is omnipotent accuse us heathens of "removing" god from--everything? They have the power to give us the power to take away their god's power. And then they freak because they gave us the power to take away their god's power! I am going to "hell" and will have control of the thermostat!
-
Permalink Reply by Jedi Wanderer on -
Ugh, how disgusting. Hard to even respond to such idiocy. Maybe best response would be, "what happened to 'thou shalt not judge'?"
-
Permalink Reply by James Kz on -
You'd think that with all the people threatened with going to Hell, that Hell, Michigan would be rolling in the dough.
-
Permalink Reply by Future on
-
I finished a book a couple weeks ago - the Chamber, by John Grisham, about a racist on death row for murder. In the hour before his execution, a priest asks him to confess all his sins so that he may be forgiven. The convict is skeptical because there is so much to confess, but the priest assures him that god has unlimited forgiveness as long as you believe in him, and the convict admits to a lifetime of hideous hate crimes. I thought to myself, how fucking reckless is that? Spend your life being as evil as you can, and in the end just admit it to a priest and you can what? Go to heaven? If the reward for admitting it all just before you die isn't getting into heaven, then you are headed to hell anyways so what the hell is the point in confessing and "surrendering" to some god? If the reward for doing so is getting to heaven, then doesn't that kind of make the whole religion thing a huge detriment to society? Kill all your life and still be able to get your peice of the kingdom, and then all those actual good people who die have to share it with a life long killer?
-
Permalink Reply by DarkBlack on -
When I was in Sunday school this came up a few times over the years, they never really explained why we shoud not sin all we want and repent later but gave some dodge about pleasing god and possible extra reward in heaven.
As far as I know deathbed confessions or repenting were popular in the middle ages.
-
Permalink Reply by Ruth Anthony-Gardner on -
Great paraphrase, Jedi Wanderer
...believe in what I believe in or you will suffer. How? Well, you'll have to die to find out.
Your point about thought crimes is provocative. I can see "thought crime" as a useful point in discounting "going to hell" condemnations.It puts Xian insult into Orwellian context.
-
Permalink Reply by Jedi Wanderer on
-
Thanks Ruth, but I can't take the credit. Hitchens pointed it out to me, I'm just paying it fwd.
-
Permalink Reply by Tim on
-
Telling this grotesquely an vulgar delusion to children is beyond disheartening! It robs a child of there innocence, of there very essence. One can only ponder the horrific indoctrination bestowed upon children of Wahhabi Islam, Westboro baptist, seven day Adventists, an any other more radical theistic cult I left out. Being terrified of hell an damnation, terrified to make a mistake. To have ones little developing mind imprisoned this way IS not morality.. It's slavery!
-
Permalink Reply by michele ricketts on
-
Seriously hell does not seem to have made a dent in sinning when you look down the centuries. If people seriously had believed in it they would have taken fright and abstained and even IN CASE IT was sinning.
Hell conditions children in childhood. That is the only reason adults really did/do believe in hell. It's a pavlov's dog response from early brainwashing and bulling in childhood. Ingrained. In theory ;not much in practise. Medaevil times in fact as nasty as it was ribald.My cat Fluffy was man-handled by two young boys who were just having fun being as she was trapped in a basement. I mean to their minds they were not physically injuring her. Now she meows with sweet querelousness on being picked up but her heart is beating madly anyway. Same thing.
-
Permalink Reply by DarkBlack on
-
This is only part of it.
At the very foundation of christianity is the idea of redemption to forgive sins (most of all original sin, just to get everyone). Original sin and many of the sins are only a problem according to the bible and other 'dangers" (demons, satan, etc) only exist if the religion is true.
Which boils down to: "Accept jesus as your lord so that he can help you with problems that are only real if you believe".
-
Permalink Reply by Jedi Wanderer on
-
Good point DarkBlack. This conversation has gotten much better than I thought it would be when I posted it.
CONNECT WITH ATHEIST NEXUS
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
Joan Denoo commented on Ruth Anthony-Gardner's group Hang With Friends"The Breast Cancer Site
I'm all hooked up, first drip will take 1 1/2 hours. Five hours till finished. I feel fine, not a bit of pain; staff at Cancer Care Northwest have so many skills, patients getting chemo all have positive attitudes,…"
Loren Miller commented on DeafAtheist's group Signing Atheists"Greets, peeps. I'm not formally trained in ASL, though I know a few signs. Once at a customer's site, I saw a deaf programmer struggling with a problem with the VMS operating system. I remembered the sign for HELP,…"
Signing Atheists
I was going to set up a group for Deaf Atheists, but figured I'd probably be alone in here if I did that so I figured I'd open it to anyone who knows sign language or even interested in learning it.
Loren Miller replied to Eric's discussion Vatican halted trial for man accused by deaf boys in the group Signing Atheists"I don't know if this is the trial you're referring to, and unfortunately, your link no longer refers to an active page, but back in February of 2013, HBO aired a brilliant if disturbing piece: Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence in the House of God,…"
Dennis Michael Pennington commented on blue pashmina's blog post Not believing in an afterlife does not mean i am a "sad' person."Living forever is not what it's cracked up to be. I'm not sad, but I do get tired more often. Imagine how sad and tired you would be after a few hundred years of singing praises and hosannas with God. Maybe it wouldn't even take that…"
© 2013 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.
