 |
The World's Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!
NPR - synthetic DNA working in living cells - check it out...
www.npr.org For the first time, scientists have synthesized DNA in the lab, put it into a cell, which is now growing and multiplying. This means that we're one step closer to creating life. But some bioethicists are asking: Are we playing God? And what happens if artificial organisms leave the lab?
What does this portend?
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jaume on -
"Now we only need to synthetize a soul to save these cells from eternal damnation."
-
Permalink Reply by Howard S. Dunn on -
THAT definitely tickled me. Bravo, mon ami - tres drole.
-
Permalink Reply by Dave Rogers on -
Are we playing God?
I laugh whenever I hear this question.
If they were playing God, absolutely nothing would be happening.
-
Permalink Reply by Goz on -
Love that! I can just see a scientist above that saying holding a test tube as a t shirt design.
-
Permalink Reply by Howard S. Dunn on
-
A - I pasted the blurb BTW - I was mostly interested in what people think about the breakthrough and what it might prove and what it might lead to. Also, 'playing god' can be used metaphorically - as in the valid questions posed in MS's Frankenstein.
-
Permalink Reply by Secular Forces 2013 on -
-
Permalink Reply by Roy The Infidel on -
Why am I not surprised it's Craig Venter?
I added a video (when I first joined A|N) where Venter takes Richard Dawkins to a tour in his lab facility.
Playing god? Well, somebody's gotta do it. Like it or not, in the future we are the gods.
-
Permalink Reply by Stephen Moore on -
From the NPR article: "Up until now, organisms have come into being on their own, as it were; they've evolved on their own," Kaebnick says.
Not entirely true. Canis lupis familiaris, Felis silvestris catus, Bos primagenius taurus and B. p. indicus, and Ovis aries aries are just a few species that evolved as a result of human intervention, which is to say, not on their own.
It is a great technological achievement, but it's basically an extension of what Homo sapiens sapiens have been doing for 10,000+ years. Sophisticated Knowledge + Sophisticated Tools = Sophisticated Outcomes.
Are we playing God?
"Playing God" a moronic idea that holds humanity back. Any species able to manipulate it's environment to it's advantage (even if in the long term it turns out to be a disadvantage) will do so. We human beings are no different. Of course there are ethical concerns which ought be considered, but that's a separate issue. If there is a legitimate concern about 'playing God', then we may as well abandon medicine.
And what happens if artificial organisms leave the lab?
Anything from the organism dying because it can not survive 'in the wild', to a major pandemic that kills off 98% of the human population. The organism could even do what it was designed to do, and only that. But that's what biohazard protections are all about: systems and procedures together with containment facilities to study the organism. We're not all running scared because Smallpox, Anthrax, Ebola or any other deadly organism being studied might leave the lab that's just down the street.
-
Permalink Reply by Dylan Michael McFarland on -
What will happen? It's the exact same species that already exists. The only difference is the origin of the DNA. Nothing will happen.
-
Permalink Reply by Daniel on -
Not a lot of love for the bioethics, eh?
>What does this portend?
I'll go devils advocate on this one. Bio terror and another weapons race.
Military funding says offensive capability comes first, maybe a Bin Laden targeting virus?
-
Permalink Reply by Super fluid on -
What Venter has done is somewhat interesting, technically, to biology nerds like myself, but it is of very little consequence. At least, it doesn't quite live up to the hype attributed to it by the news coverage. Best case scenario, this type of synth-bio work will lead to new chassis for other synth-bio/genetic engineering work, replacing E. coli as the de facto model. If anyone is interested in the other side of synthetic biology I recommend checking out iGem's website. It is a undergraduate synthetic biology competition held annually at MIT. Read through the past years abstracts, cool stuff. Something else, all of the biobrick's created by teams are opensource and freely available, even to home enthusiasts, yup they're out there. Opensource is decidedly NOT Venter's style.
CONNECT WITH ATHEIST NEXUS
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
Teresita Mattox posted a blog postBest Free Online Dating Sites
Free Online Dating Site - Whereloveisfound.comFalling in love might feel closer to a daydream than possible for many with busy lives. But it is possible and the WhereLoveIsFound team have created a dating experience "100 percent dedicated to the community and providing a place for people to find genuine love and happiness." Below they explain why loveless singles should try their site.What inspired WhereLoveIsFound?Whereloveisfound.com was inspired by love, building a community for people all…See More
Loren Miller replied to Loren Miller's discussion Latest Activity?"After a bit of thought, I've come up with a list of the basic items which used to be found on a member's profile page and whether they are currently present in the new profile, at least as it is displayed on mine:
Member's name &…"
Loren Miller commented on John Hutcheson's blog post Are the media too giddy over the Pope?"Wouldn't know, really. The last couple days, the US news media has been focused (for good or ill) on this EF-5 tornado which wiped out a considerable portion of Moore, Oklahoma. When you only have half an hour to report national and…"
Loren Miller replied to Loren Miller's discussion Latest Activity?"For that matter, when the upgrade was originally applied, I had my photo slide show on my profile as with the old layout. Now I don't. SOMETHING got tripped over!"
Debra Stevenson replied to matthew greenberg's discussion Pope Francis says even Atheists go to Heaven"I wish the RCC would reform itself along with the main branch of the LDS church, the SDA's and the JW's ( they desperately need reform , none of the eighty something splinter groups can be called liberal in all actuality). …"
© 2013 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.
