This has really been bugging me. 

I saw this interview on CNN: John King, USA a few days ago. The service man interviewed was shot by a snipper, died ... I mean, gone, flat lined ... only to be revived 15 minutes later. Luckily, he suffered no brain damage and is able to describe the entire process of dying. 

I am very disappointed that John King didn't ask probing questions about the existence of "God". It is clear in this interview that there is no "God". The evidence contradicting the existence of "God" is right here! 

If anyone on this forum has Bill Mahr's email address, please forward this to him.


-Tom

Tags: video

Views: 17

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

"Many people think this is a god experience. How can we refute this? "

It's not up to us to refute anything. The burden of proof remains with the ones making the claim.It's up to them to provide evidence,rather than supposition and speculation masquerading as evidence.

The assertion that near death experiences even imply(suggest),let alone infer (conclude) proof of survival after death falls under the category of argument from ignorance. Specifically argument from incredulity IE; "I lack the knowledge, intelligence or imagination to think of anything else therefore God did it.

That many people believe a thing is irrelevant as an argument.It's another logical fallacy, 'argumentum ad populum'.('appeal to the people' aka argument by consensus and argument by numbers)
I appreciated the fact that the Captain made no mention of god, which he almost certainly would have were he a christian. When asked about NDEs he asserted that they don't exist (or he's needs to change the way he's living his life).
I agree with you there and am glad he didn't make a mention of a god.
I don't bother to use logical arguments against emotional claims. It never comes to anything.
There was an experiment using the centrifugal force simulators that are used for simulating the g-force of high speed travel in jets. In the experiment they made hundreds of pilots black out...thier description of peacefulness, white light etc was identical to NDE.

"I fell asleeep and had a weird dream...GOd must be real!" Niether does lack of such dream make any implication towards the existance of GOD.
What the "mind" experiences as it is dying may sound interesting but for the purposes of acting as a witness in God's trial I don't give it much credence.
I am very disappointed that John King didn't ask probing questions about the existence of "God".

Why? The issue is rather irrelevant to the purpose of Captain Mantz being interviewed: advocacy of the provision of psychological services for combat personnel. Sure, the story is wrapped up in the 'dead for fifteen minutes' angle — which is amazing in itself — but if that is what allows Captain Mantz to better enable his advocacy, well and good.

It is clear in this interview that there is no "God". The evidence contradicting the existence of "God" is right here!

No. It is evidence that he did not experience an 'after-life' during the fifteen minutes of his death. Nothing more, nothing less. Though it is common to conflate the two claims — that there is an after-life and that there is a god — it is a mistake to do so. Each claim requires its own evidence. Evidence for one claim may support the other claim, but it is not necessarily so that it will.

Also, the experience of Captain Mantz is one data point, and one data point does not support or refute a claim.

RSS

Support Atheist Nexus

Donate Today

Donate

 

Help Nexus When You Buy From Amazon

Amazon

AJY

 

Latest Activity

Atheist in FundyLand replied to Bertold Brautigan's discussion How can people be good without god?
1 minute ago
Joan Denoo liked Bertold Brautigan's discussion How can people be good without god?
9 minutes ago
Tom Sarbeck replied to Bertold Brautigan's discussion How can people be good without god?
12 minutes ago
Joan Denoo replied to John Jubinsky's discussion Experimental Ebola Serum May Be In Use On Americans in the group ORIGINS: UNIVERSE, LIFE, HUMANKIND, AND DARWIN
12 minutes ago
Joan Denoo replied to John Jubinsky's discussion Experimental Ebola Serum May Be In Use On Americans in the group ORIGINS: UNIVERSE, LIFE, HUMANKIND, AND DARWIN
23 minutes ago
Tom Sarbeck replied to Bertold Brautigan's discussion How can people be good without god?
24 minutes ago
Atheist in FundyLand posted a discussion
26 minutes ago
HPhan replied to John Jubinsky's discussion Hawking Says Higgs Boson Could Destroy the Universe in the group ORIGINS: UNIVERSE, LIFE, HUMANKIND, AND DARWIN
33 minutes ago
Chris G commented on Sylvain Duford's group Eco-Logical: A Group for Environmentalists
41 minutes ago
HPhan liked Sylvain Duford's group Eco-Logical: A Group for Environmentalists
44 minutes ago
HPhan joined Sylvain Duford's group
44 minutes ago
HPhan replied to Steph S.'s discussion Scientists report first semiaquatic dinosaur, Spinosaurus in the group ORIGINS: UNIVERSE, LIFE, HUMANKIND, AND DARWIN
47 minutes ago

© 2014   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service