Atheist Nexus

The World’s Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!

I was taking the Political Compass Test, and I noticed something interesting... there's no "neutral" option for answers, which is bad because some of these questions seem to be biased, particularly toward libertarianism.  What I mean is, I seem to be forced into appearing to disagree with a statement that is actually a far more complicated issue than is presented to me.  (Skip down to the bottom of this post if you want the smoking gun.)

Here are some examples of question bias:

  • "Military action that defies international law is sometimes justified."  Is the international law corrupt, or is it justified?  And what is the goal of the military action?  "Sometimes" is a very vague concept.
  • "Controlling inflation is more important than controlling unemployment."  When?  How bad is unemployment?  How bad is inflation?  This isn't always an either/or situation.
  • "The freer the market, the freer the people."  Does this even mean anything?  It's like saying "fancy is as fancy does" or some other such BS.
  • "All authority should be questioned."  Asking questions doesn't mean being anti-authority or even necessarily disagreeing with said authority.  This is far too ambiguous a statement to base a political ideology upon.
  • "All people have their rights, but it is better for all of us that different sorts of people should keep to their own kind."  Which people?  There's a difference between expecting blacks to keep to their own kind and serial rapists to keep to their own kind, for example.
  • "The most important thing for children to learn is to accept discipline."  I don't know of anyone who would say this is literally the most important thing a child could learn.  This question is obviously biased so as to be anti-authority (pro-libertarian) and also has nothing to do with political ideology anyway.
  • "When you are troubled, it's better not to think about it, but to keep busy with more cheerful things."  Not even relevant!  Come on!
  • "A significant advantage of a one-party state is that it avoids all the arguments that delay progress in a democratic political system."  That may actually be a significant advantage... doesn't mean I'd actually prefer a one-party state.  Nuance, people, nuance!
  • "Abstract art that doesn't represent anything shouldn't be considered art at all."  Lol wut.
  • "Astrology accurately explains many things."  I quit.

So now, the ultimate challenge: I "strongly disagreed" with literally everything on the list and ran the score.  The results were way into libertarianism, though on the line between left and right.  They did manage to balance the left/right scale, but they were not at all balanced on the libertarian/authoritarian scale.  A well-written test will score perfectly center if the questions are all answered the same.  This test was clearly written in such a way as to make people squeemish about agreeing with the statements, thus allowing them to nudge their own score into libertarian territory.

In short, the Political Compass Test is a recruiting tool for an underdog political agenda, and is not to be taken seriously.

Tags: Libertiarian, Political Compass, bias, propaganda

Views: 254

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

"fancy is as fancy does"  lol.  Agreed, the test begs some questions.

You are completely right for as far as I can see The Nerd.

I've done the test and I came out on the extreme left and libertarian side. I would have never guessed, even if I look back on the answers that I have given, several of my answers are completely opposite of what libertarianism stands for.

That is so cool that you caught that!

Have you taken a class on how to write tests? 

I remember in one of my classes we had to write a Likert Scale test. It was harder than it looked. 

Anyway, thanks for the heads up on that Political Compass Test. 

RSS

Support Nexus

Click to Buy Amazon items and help A|N

Advertisements

Heathen's Guide

Skeptic Money

Sex and God

Humanistic Judaism

Your Ad Here

Helpful Items

 

Search Atheist Nexus:
Translate page:

 

Social Networking Links:
 

Latest Activity

Greg DeMott commented on Greg DeMott's blog post I don't fit in
1 minute ago
Tammy S replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
2 minutes ago
Sentient Biped replied to Joan Denoo's discussion The secret to the immortality of McDonald’s food in the group Politics, Economics, and Religion
2 minutes ago
Jessica replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
5 minutes ago
Joan Denoo liked Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
6 minutes ago
Tammy S commented on moJoe's group Atheist News
8 minutes ago
Joan Denoo commented on moJoe's group Atheist News
8 minutes ago
Kelsey Jo Lewis commented on golnaz's group Feminist Atheists
9 minutes ago
Tammy S replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
10 minutes ago
Ruth Anthony-Gardner replied to Evil For All Time's discussion Greyhounds: The Coolest Commercial On This Planet in the group Atheist News
10 minutes ago
Sentient Biped replied to Joan Denoo's discussion Tomato recommendations in the group Godless in the garden
13 minutes ago
Jessica replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
14 minutes ago
Susan Stanko commented on moJoe's group Atheist News
19 minutes ago
Don Weller replied to Stephanie Chiller's discussion nothing can come out of nothing- creation story discussion and how a person couldn't of just came to be and came as a adult
25 minutes ago
Tammy S replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
27 minutes ago
Idaho Spud liked Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden
31 minutes ago
Tor Hershman commented on Dane's group YouTube Atheists
33 minutes ago
Joan Denoo replied to Joan Denoo's discussion The secret to the immortality of McDonald’s food in the group Politics, Economics, and Religion
34 minutes ago
Tammy S replied to Jessica's discussion ACLU encourages and succeeds in getting a NC School Board to Ban prayer at all Upcoming Events!
35 minutes ago
Tor Hershman commented on Ivy's group Atheist Humor
36 minutes ago

© 2012   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Brother Richard.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service