The World’s Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!
Argument against creationism
One of my most recent articles on creationism: http://www.rustylime.com/show_article.php?id=3756#comm29238
After the annoying threats and troll commenters were done insulting me over my anti creationist rhetoric, I received an interesting comment:
"Creationists need to consider that the bible is not a scientific textbook. If it was then genesis chapter one wouldn't contradict chapter two. In chapter one, humans are created last after the plants and animals, in chapter two humans are created before the plants and animals."
I thought that people might like to discuss my reply:
The lack of consitency in any holy book of any religion suggests that it is written as a phylosophical perspective rather than a scientific deduction, thus, and as you suggest, it should never be interpreted literally. There is no evidence to suggest a creator but much to back up evolution. Sure, we still need to work on it and we will, as we evolve our ability and excitement to add on our predecessors' conclusions does also evolve.
Not understanding is forgivable, but simply saying "god did it" is a stab against humanity!
After the annoying threats and troll commenters were done insulting me over my anti creationist rhetoric, I received an interesting comment:
"Creationists need to consider that the bible is not a scientific textbook. If it was then genesis chapter one wouldn't contradict chapter two. In chapter one, humans are created last after the plants and animals, in chapter two humans are created before the plants and animals."
I thought that people might like to discuss my reply:
The lack of consitency in any holy book of any religion suggests that it is written as a phylosophical perspective rather than a scientific deduction, thus, and as you suggest, it should never be interpreted literally. There is no evidence to suggest a creator but much to back up evolution. Sure, we still need to work on it and we will, as we evolve our ability and excitement to add on our predecessors' conclusions does also evolve.
Not understanding is forgivable, but simply saying "god did it" is a stab against humanity!
Tags: atheism, creationism, science
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jaume on -
Don't lose your time. There's no valid argument against creationism from a creationist point of view. If I were one, I would retort it's yet another proof that God is all-powerful, since He's not limited by the constraints of time and causality as we frail humans are.
-
Permalink Reply by Jake Farr-Wharton on -
Fair point.
-
Permalink Reply by Tarquin St John Sh'gn'sty on -
I've never really understood the whole creationist/ID issue;it's a religious doctrine, to be put in the same box as Flat earthers and Holocaust deniers. Evolution is fact.There is not now and has never been a debate about what is to me a non-issue.
That the literalists seem unable to grasp the difference between a theory and a hypothesis is their problem. I decline to argue with such people, just as I don't bother trying to hold a conversation with a goldfish.
Support Nexus
Click to Buy Amazon items and help A|N
Advertisements
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
Chris Breman replied to Don Weller's discussion Better Luck Next Time? (a year after the NON-apocalypse)
Dust replied to Scott Bidstrup's discussion Psychology Today: The Fear of Atheism in the group ORIGINS: UNIVERSE, LIFE, HUMANKIND, AND DARWIN
Joan Denoo replied to Jedi Wanderer's discussion When is Murder justified? in the group Wanderer's Group
Write4U commented on Nate Julian's blog post New to open atheism, here is part of what recently allowed me to publicly affirm my beliefs.
George hawkins posted a videoWay To Go America, Way To Go...
Website: http://www.gphhawkinsrationalistsociety.weebly.com/ My Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/gphhawkins Podcast: http://www.blogtalkradio.com/gphh...
Joan Denoo replied to Jedi Wanderer's discussion Fairness is Essential for Economic Growth in the group Wanderer's Group© 2012 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Brother Richard.
