"@Rachel: Realizing I have only one life to live also encourages me to live a happier and fuller life, as well as invest in a future I know I will not be around to appreciate. It seems only logical to me.
@Dennis: I've always wondered what it…"
 |
The World's Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!
arguing with religionist on "opening up" to god
Here's a typical argument of religionist for "opening up" to god by an atheist:
Certainly I would never try to prove by scientific method that God is. However, if you are open to experimentation, I suggest you give God an opportunity to actually prove Himself. Here’s what I recommend: Tell him (as if you believe He’s real) that you would like for Him to prove Himself by saving you from your errors in life (sin). Say something like :” If You are there, please begin to change me to be as You would have me to be.
Of course if You are there and begin to affect me and change me from within, I will, of course, become a believer.” I suggest for the sake of the experiment that you speak sincerely
Here's my reply:
First, isn’t it interesting that your god always shows up where he can’t be objectively observed – exactly like a nonexistent entity.
Second, isn’t it interesting that he needs your “openness” or “permission” to do his wonderful works – just like a case of self-hypnosis by a true believer.
Third, in the remote possibility that your god is real maybe he can open himself to human goodness and stop burning people who don’t believe in him in hell for all eternity.
Certainly I would never try to prove by scientific method that God is. However, if you are open to experimentation, I suggest you give God an opportunity to actually prove Himself. Here’s what I recommend: Tell him (as if you believe He’s real) that you would like for Him to prove Himself by saving you from your errors in life (sin). Say something like :” If You are there, please begin to change me to be as You would have me to be.
Of course if You are there and begin to affect me and change me from within, I will, of course, become a believer.” I suggest for the sake of the experiment that you speak sincerely
Here's my reply:
First, isn’t it interesting that your god always shows up where he can’t be objectively observed – exactly like a nonexistent entity.
Second, isn’t it interesting that he needs your “openness” or “permission” to do his wonderful works – just like a case of self-hypnosis by a true believer.
Third, in the remote possibility that your god is real maybe he can open himself to human goodness and stop burning people who don’t believe in him in hell for all eternity.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Linda on -
Third, in the remote possibility that your god is real maybe he can open himself to human goodness and stop burning people who don’t believe in him in hell for all eternity.
They were all excellent points. I think this is the best point.
-
Permalink Reply by Jo Jerome on -
Besides interjecting something like improving oneself as "proof" that god did it and you didn't do it yourself, what a wonderfully backhanded way for that Theist to tell you you're fucked up and in need of improvement.
I mean we certainly can all use improvement in our selves, but it's this kind of condescending, insult-in-sheep's-clothing that really tops the crap sandwich that is Theistic Rhetoric.
Finally, I thought it's a sin to demand proof from god? "Blessed is he who has not seen yet still believes ... though shalt not tempt the lord thy god." But since this Theist has put it out there as fair game, I'd ask for more tangible "proof" that would be much harder than, say, self-improvement, to attribute to natural causes. E.g.;
"Dear god; If you are there, please turn this pine tree into a fruit fly before my very eyes. Better yet, let me get several more witnesses and a video camera. Ok, go."
Even then, I bet Criss Angel could turn a pine tree into a fruit fly. After all, he's made things like motorcycles and mountains disappear, right?
-
Permalink Reply by UUMom on -
That's true and I'm not going to "argue" the point with you.
My take is different, though, in that the human brain is "miraculous" (sorry, the English language is limited in expressing this) in the way it works and can make you feel. The feeling of openness can make you experience something like "nirvana" - some people think that is a God-experience. I don't care as long as they don't make laws that interfere with the human experience that doesn't hurt other people. Their feelings and brain experiences are as "real" to them as mine are to me (we don't "know" how creation happened - it's all theory). I love this Ted video about the experience of a stroke victim who's a neuroanatomist who specializes in the postmortem investigation of the human brain.
-
Permalink Reply by eric stone on -
I don't think we should fear this self-hypnosis method of theirs but instead analyze and expose it. Did your former atheist friend turned fundy now believe that non-believers should burn in hell? If not, maybe he's not really a fundy.
CONNECT WITH ATHEIST NEXUS
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
Easton Le commented on blue pashmina's blog post Not believing in an afterlife does not mean i am a "sad' person."Loren, i was thinking about you and your likely response as i was writing this post. i know your rightful indignation with the papacy and share it, albeit probably with slightly less ire.
i must say that i just freaking love your pov.…"
Easton Le commented on Debra Stevenson's blog post Some Wiccans and their seeking approval from Christians"I suppose in regions of the country where Christianity is a major influence in local culture working towards a level of acceptance would be in Wicca's best interest. When I visited a gem shop in the bible belt with one of my friends I learned…"
Loren Miller replied to matthew greenberg's discussion Pope Francis says even Atheists go to Heaven"Hmmm, an outreach to atheists from the pope? I wonder ... is this an attempt at engagement and maybe a dialogue ... or is it an act of desperation from an organization which may finally be recognizing that it is failing at both engagement and…"
Karim R. joined Darrel Ray's group
Recovering from Religion
Unless you were raised by atheist parents, you probably had some recovering to do when you left religion. The purpose of RR is to provide a landing place for people when they jump from religion. With local support groups throughout the US, Canada, UK, and Australia, and real-time resources accessible to everyone, RR is where to turn when faith has lost its luster.See More
Ruth Anthony-Gardner replied to Ruth Anthony-Gardner's discussion Methane, more scary than we thought in the group Eco-Logical: A Group for Environmentalists"In addition to the methane spike over Antarctica there was
Is the permafrost's integrity breaking down?
In sum, the half-life of methane in the atmosphere depends upon available hydroxyl ions to break it down. The oft cited values of methane…"
Easton Le commented on Randall Smith's blog post The Rednecks are coming, the Rednecks are coming"Hello, Randall. Did you move to the region or have you lived there your entire life? I'm just curious because even my friends in the military who weren't rednecks and grew up in the region still loved motorcycles and racing. They…"
Sentient Biped commented on Sentient Biped's group Godless in the garden"Rainy for several days now. Down into the 40s. Not much ambition.
Some of the irises look nice, anyway.
"
© 2013 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.
